MANUAL MINORS
A common clinical scenario is the suspicion of a fracture despite initial X-rays showing no visible bone abnormalities. This can occur due to fractures that are not easily detectable on standard radiological studies, especially in the early stages of injury.
Examples include stress fractures, occult fractures, or fractures in difficult-to-visualise areas such as the scaphoid (wrist), femoral neck, talus, or ribs. Patients present with localised pain, swelling, and difficulty bearing weight, but the initial X-ray may be negative.
Diagnosis
The diagnosis of a suspected fracture with a normal X-ray is based on the patient’s clinical presentation. Typical signs include intense localised pain, tenderness on palpation of the suspected area, swelling, and, in some cases, functional limitation.
X-rays are the first imaging test, but fractures may not be visible immediately after trauma. If the clinical suspicion is high, the X-ray should be repeated after 10 to 14 days, or more sensitive imaging studies should be considered.
Additional Tests
Computed Tomography (CT): Used to identify complex or occult fractures, especially in areas like the spine, pelvis, or joints.
Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI): The best option for detecting stress fractures, occult fractures, or associated soft tissue damage. It is useful for identifying early bone changes following injury.
Bone Scan: May be used for stress fractures or when MRI is unavailable; it detects increased bone metabolic activity due to the fracture.
Differential Diagnosis
Condition | Key Differentiation |
|---|---|
Bone contusion | Localised pain after trauma, without fracture evidence on X-ray. |
Sprain or ligament strain | Localised joint pain, no visible fracture, usually associated with joint instability. |
Stress fracture | Progressive pain worsened by activity, visible on MRI or bone scan, not always on initial X-ray. |
Articular cartilage injury | Joint pain, no fracture signs on X-ray, but restricted movement. |
Bone infection (osteomyelitis) | Chronic pain and inflammation, often with fever; visible on MRI or bone scan. |
Emergency Management
In the case of suspected fracture with a normal X-ray, it is crucial not to rule out a fracture solely based on negative imaging. The affected area should be immobilised to prevent further damage, using splints or orthopaedic devices.
Resting the affected limb, applying ice, and administering NSAIDs for pain management are recommended. If clinical suspicion remains high, the patient should be referred for additional imaging or orthopaedic evaluation.
Definitive Treatment
Definitive treatment depends on the diagnosis and location of the fracture. Some possible situations include:
Stress fractures: Require rest, immobilisation, and, in some cases, an orthopaedic boot or splint. Intense physical activity should be avoided for at least 6 to 8 weeks. Stress fractures in areas with poor blood supply (such as the scaphoid or femoral neck) may require surgical treatment.
Occult fractures: If confirmed on later studies like MRI or CT, treatment will depend on the type of fracture (conservative or surgical). Immobilisation is essential in both cases.
Bone contusions or ligament injuries: These are managed conservatively with rest, temporary immobilisation, and rehabilitation depending on the severity of the injury.
Follow-up
In all cases, follow-up is crucial to assess the progression of the injury. If symptoms persist or worsen, repeat imaging or additional testing is necessary to confirm the presence of fractures or associated complications.
A suspected fracture with a normal X-ray requires careful monitoring to avoid missed injuries and ensure proper recovery.
Comments